Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats Reviews 2018

If you have more than one cat in your home, you know how important a clean litter box can be. Your cats have very different personalities, and this means they may also have different quirks when using the litter box. You may have an active digger who throws dust into the air and leaves more litter outside of the box than inside.

Or you may have a cat like my younger female who doesn’t cover her feces very well, causing serious odor issues for my household. We will give you some great tips on how to manage the maintenance of multiple cats in your household. Then we will review some of the best cat litter for multiple cats that are available on the market today.

Quick Comparison Chart: Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

What Are Some Things You Can Do to Manage Your Multiple Cat Litter Box?

Divide and Conquer

If your household has more than one cat and you are only providing one litter box for them, it is time for a change. You should have the same number of litter boxes as you have cats.

I know, just the thought of managing one litter box may be enough to fill the bravest heart with dread. But more than one?

I felt the same way. I have a 2-cat household, and keeping up with one litter box was more than enough work for me. But when I began researching cat behavior, the recommendations for adding another litter box seemed to make sense. My two cats had different litter box habits (the older cat is extremely tidy, and tends to dig a great deal. The younger cat is not so careful and doesn’t fully cover up her waste, which drove the older cat crazy.)

Once I added a litter box, they each tended to use their own box. It took an extra minute or two a day to clean the two boxes, but the litter boxes stayed cleaner and freer of odor than they did when there was only one litter box.

Use Enough Litter

Since cat litter isn’t cheap, we all tend to be frugal when it comes to restocking the litter box after a full changing of litter. Your litter boxes will operate better if there is an adequate amount of clean litter in the box. The minimal amount of litter that you should keep in your litter boxes is 2 inches; 3 inches is better. 

Deal with Tracking

If you have a cat that tends to track litter outside of the box, you may be familiar with the unwelcome feeling of sandy cat litter on the bottom of bare feet as you approach the litter box. As you search for the best cat litter for multiple cats, you want to look for a cat litter that isn’t too lightweight, as that type of litter tends to cling to your cat’s feet. 

There are some other things you can do to decrease the amount of litter that is tracked outside the litter box. The simple purchase of a cat litter mat that can catch the cat litter that is kicked or tracked outside the litter box is an easy way to decrease the amount of cat litter underfoot. 

Another way to decrease the amount of litter you find outside the litter box is to change the type of litter box you are using. A litter box with high sides is one way to contain the cat litter better

Finally, no matter what you do, cat litter will occasionally find its way outside the litter box. Developing the habit of regularly sweeping the area around your cat litter box is a necessary part of controlling cat litter outside the box. 

What Should You Consider When Searching for the Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats?

Cat Litter that is Highly Absorbent, Preferably a Clumping Type Litter

If you have more than one cat in the house, the cat litter box sees a lot of traffic daily. The best cat litter for multiple cats will be designed to be highly absorbent in order to handle the amount of urine that will be deposited there. Highly absorbent cat litter will either be a clumping variety or a non-clumping variety. 

Clumping litter is generally considered the better choice due to its ability to make litter box clean up much easier. Clumping litter soaks up urine, sealing it into a ball that is easy to remove from the box. Since it forms clumps so quickly, odors are contained within the clumps, decreasing the urine odor normally associated with the litter box. 

Cat Litter that Contains Neutralizing Ingredients

Cat litters are designed with different views of how to manage offensive odors. Some cat litters have artificial fragrances added, in an attempt to cover up the odor of urine and waste. A cat has a very sensitive sense of smell, and so they may avoid using the litter box if it is a scented litter.

The best cat litter for multiple cats will neutralize the odors as opposed to covering them up with chemical fragrances. Consider litters that contain ingredients such as baking soda or carbon, both effective agents in the fight against odors.

Cat Litter that Doesn’t Create a Lot of Dust

One of the problems an owner of multiple cats has to face is dealing with dust as well as litter that is either tracked or kicked outside the litter box. Cats have different approaches to using the litter box: some spend a lot of time digging in the box while others make their visits very short. In either case, you do not want to settle on a cat litter that is too dusty, as the dust can create asthma-type symptoms for your cat. 

It is almost impossible to totally eliminate dust in the litter box, but there are some cat litters on the market that do not cause huge clouds of dust. This is one of the considerations you should have in mind as you search for the best cat litter for multiple cats.

Our Review of the Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

Here is our list of the 5 best cat litters for multiple cats.  We have also provided a easy to navigate comparison chart with our ratings of the products reviewed.

Fresh Step Clumping Cat Litter, Simply Unscented

best cat litter clumping

This cat litter is an unscented clumping litter that was designed to quickly absorb liquid by trapping the odor and creating easy- to-remove clumps.

Another good feature in the Fresh Step Clumping Cat Litter is that it uses an activated carbon as a natural deodorizer; the carbon removes odor from feces as well as strong-smelling urine.

Pros

  • check-circle
    Purposefully designed for multiple cat homes
  • check-circle
    No artificial scents or perfumes added to this litter
  • check-circle
    Added the ingredient activated carbon in order to capture and remove odor from the litter box
  • check-circle
    Easy to maintain due to its clumping ability

Cons

  • times-circle
    The clumps can sometimes harden too much, clinging to other litter in the box
  • times-circle
    Although there are no added fragrances, the litter smells strongly, probably due to the clay used
  • times-circle
    Although it is called a low dust litter, the clay does create dust issues
  • times-circle
    Sometimes the clay uses more clean litter when it creates the clump than other types of clumping agents

Purina Tidy Cats Instant Action Clumping Cat Litter

best cat litter for multiple cats

Purina Tidy Cats Instant Action is a clumping litter designed for a multiple-cat home.

Designed to quickly trap obnoxious odors by clumping around urine, this cat litter also contains neutralizing action to overpower the odor of urine.

If you are looking for a cat litter that quickly traps the odor of urine, this may be the best option for you.

Pros

  • check-circle
    Designed especially for multiple cat homes to instantly stop the odor of urine and ammonia
  • check-circle
    Provides long-lasting odor control
  • check-circle
    This is a clumping litter, making it easy to scoop
  • check-circle
    Created to neutralize odors in addition to locking odor away by clumping action

Cons

  • times-circle
    This is not an unscented cat litter, so if your cat doesn't like scents than this might not be for your cat
  • times-circle
    Sometimes there is a sticky residue in the bottom of the litter pan, possibly created because this is a clay-based litter

World's Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Clumping Formula, 15 Pound Bag (2 Pack)

clumping cat litter 2 packs

The World's Best Cat Litter for multiple cats is different from the other cat litters on our list because it uses whole kernel corn to effectively control odor and provide quick clumping.

This litter claims that its formula is 99% dust-free. It is also 100 percent natural in its components, and it comes with a money back guarantee, which is why it made our best cat litters for multiple cats list.

Pros

  • check-circle
    This cat litter offers excellent odor control
  • check-circle
    created from all natural products, a special perk for people who are trying to avoid chemicals: this one is organic
  • check-circle
    Quickly clumps, allowing for easy removal during daily scooping of the litter box
  • check-circle
    Low dust
  • check-circle
    Cat litter is flushable and it is septic tank safe
  • check-circle
    The Kitty litter is lightweight
  • check-circle
    This litter clumps into smaller balls, which means you aren’t wasting clean cat litter

Cons

  • times-circle
    Although the fact that this cat litter is lightweight is actually a benefit, it can be a deficit if your cat loves to perch on the side of the litter box: the lightweight nature of the litter makes the litter box easier to tip over
  • times-circle
    It is one of the more expensive brands of cat litter on the market
  • times-circle
    If overloaded with urine, this cat litter can have an unpleasant smell

Fresh Step Extreme with Febreze Freshness Clumping Cat Litter

dust free cat litter

In our search for the best cat litter for multiple cats, we found Fresh Step with Febreze, a multi-cat litter that uses Febreze to eliminate the strong odors of ammonia.

This cat litter uses carbon to deodorize the litter box contents, as well as an antimicrobial component to decrease the growth of bacteria in the litter.

This is a clumping litter, so urine is locked in on contact, allowing for easy removal.

Pros

  • check-circle
    This cat litter uses several techniques to eliminate odor from your litter box, including the use of Febreze as well as the use of carbon as a natural deodorizer
  • check-circle
    This litter also contains an antimicrobial agent, which limits the growth of bacteria
  • check-circle
    As a strong clumping litter, this litter forms tight clumps that are easy to remove
  • check-circle
    If your cats have very strong urine, this cat litter uses several different methods to decrease odors in the litter box while also emitting the fragrance of Febreze when your cat steps on the litter

Cons

  • times-circle
    If you are concerned about limiting the use of artificial fragrances, this is not the right litter for you
  • times-circle
    The clumping action of this litter may draw in more clean litter at times than it should
  • times-circle
    This cat litter can create a lot of dust at times

Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Litter, Multi-Cat, 28 Lbs

Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal litter is another product that we found as we looked for the best cat litter for multiple cats.

This litter was created to decrease odors without covering odor with a chemical smell.

The clumping action, created from plant-derived material, was designed to create a solid seal around any cat waste, making clumps that are easily removed.

 It also uses baking soda as a natural deodorizer. This litter guarantees no odors in the litter box for 7 days.

Pros

  • check-circle
    7 day guarantee of no odor in the litter box
  • check-circle
    Claims to be 100% free of dust
  • check-circle
    The sealing quality of the clumping agents works exceptionally well to surround cat waste so it is easy to remove without breaking apart into small fragments
  • check-circle
    It uses several methods to eliminate odors, including the use of the natural properties of baking soda to deodorize

Cons

  • times-circle
    This cat litter is artificially scented as one of the methods to eliminate odor; the use of artificial fragrance may cause problems for sensitive cats or cat owners
  • times-circle
    The litter itself resembles sand, and if you have an active digger, you may end up with more litter outside of the litter box than you would like
  • times-circle
    At times there is a sticky residue on the bottom of the litter pan that is difficult to remove

Review Round Up

After reviewing a variety of cat litter for our choice of best cat litter for multiple cats, we have reached a solid decision. The World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Clumping Formula is the clear winner.

In looking for the best cat litter for multiple cats, we wanted a product that would quickly and efficiently seal off cat feces and urine in order to limit unwanted odor. We wanted a cat litter that would enable easy scooping and lower the impact of dust and tracking. We were also hoping to limit the amount of chemicals and fragrances added to the litter.

While the Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal did a great job of sealing off feces and urine, even coming with a 7-day guarantee, the added fragrance proved to be too much for our sensitive cats. The World’s Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats did an excellent job of clumping while having no added fragrances or intolerable chemical smells.

The Fresh Step/Febreze cat litter had several different methods for decreasing odors, which we liked, but the product created too much dust in comparison with the World’s Best Cat Litter.

All in all, we find the World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Clumping Formula to be our choice for a multiple-cat household. The fact that this cat litter is made from all-natural products, making it environmentally friendly, only makes us love it more.

Quick Comparison Chart: Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

Image credits: Amazon.com

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: